The Coverage Gap

Finance // Field Note No. 07

The Coverage Gap

Compiled by the Curator · 6 min read


Most households arrive at a life insurance number in one of two ways. They accept whatever the employer provides by default, or they multiply a salary by ten because someone once said that was the rule. Both produce a number. Neither starts from the only question that matters, which is what the money would actually have to do if one income, or one person, were suddenly gone.

The rule of thumb is a starting point

Ten times income is the figure most often quoted, and it is not a bad place to begin. It is quick, it is memorable, and for a household with modest debts and no unusual obligations it may land somewhere reasonable.

Its weakness is everything it leaves out. It ignores the savings and coverage a household already has, so it can overshoot. It ignores how many dependents there are and how young, so it can badly undershoot. And it assigns a value of zero to anyone who does not draw a salary, which is the gap this piece is named for.

Start from what the money has to do

The more useful method works forward from obligations rather than backward from a paycheck. Make a list of what the household would need covered, add it up, and then subtract what already exists.

Debts to clear. Car loans, credit cards, student loans, anything that would otherwise keep drawing on a reduced income.

The mortgage. Either the full balance, or enough to keep paying it for as long as the household plans to stay.

Income to replace. The share of the lost income the household actually lives on, multiplied by the years until the youngest dependent is independent.

Costs that arrive later. Childcare that a surviving parent would now have to buy, education if you intend to fund it, and final expenses.

Then subtract existing savings and investments, and any coverage already in place, including the workplace policy. What remains is the gap. Insurers call the short version of this the DIME method: debt, income, mortgage, education. It is a readable checklist, though it shares the rule of thumb’s blind spot below.

The partner without a paycheck

A parent who stays home, or who works part-time around the children, is often left uninsured on the reasoning that there is no income to replace. There is, though. It is simply paid in hours rather than dollars.

If that partner died, the household would have to buy what they currently provide: childcare, school runs, meals, the running of the house. The cost is real and it arrives immediately. The simplest way to size it is to price those services locally and multiply by the years they would be needed. Most formulas, DIME included, do not do this on their own.

What the workplace policy is, and is not

Group life insurance through an employer is usually one or two times salary, often free or close to it, and worth having. It is rarely enough on its own, for two reasons.

The first is the amount, which comes from a salary multiple rather than from anyone’s actual needs. The second is that it is attached to the job. Coverage often ends when you leave, are laid off, or retire, sometimes with an option to convert at a much higher price. An individual policy exists alongside it precisely so that the household’s protection does not depend on staying employed in one particular place.

Term, permanent, and when the number stops mattering

Term insurance covers a fixed period, commonly ten to thirty years, and pays only if death occurs within it. It costs a fraction of permanent coverage for the same amount, which is why it is the usual choice for covering the years when dependents rely on an income. Permanent insurance, such as whole life, lasts for life and builds a cash value. Its supporters value the permanence and the forced saving; its critics point to the higher premiums and argue the difference is better invested separately. Both arguments are made in good faith, and the right answer depends on the household.

What both share is that the need is not fixed. Coverage exists to close a gap, and the gap narrows as savings grow, the mortgage shrinks and children become independent. A review every few years, and after any major change such as a new child or a new house, matters more than getting the first number exactly right.

The right amount is not the largest one. It is the one that would let the people left behind keep their footing.

A Short Reference

A worked example of the needs method, with invented round numbers. It illustrates the arithmetic only. Real figures depend on your own household, and none of this is a recommendation to buy a particular amount or type of policy.

One household, worked through

Two parents, two children aged four and seven. One parent earns $75,000; the other works part-time and handles most of the childcare. They are working out cover for the main earner.

What the money has to doAmount
Debts to clear (car loan and a credit card)$18,000
Mortgage balance$240,000
Income to replace: $45,000 a year until the youngest is 18, so 14 years$630,000
Education, a contribution toward two children$60,000
Final expenses$15,000
Total need$963,000
Less savings and investments($50,000)
Less the workplace policy, two times salary($150,000)
The gap$763,000

Rounded, that is a policy of about $750,000 to $800,000. For comparison, ten times income gives $750,000, so the rule of thumb happens to land close here, but for different reasons, and it would have missed by more with a third child or a larger mortgage.

Why the income line uses $45,000, not $75,000. The household does not need the whole salary replaced. Taxes, the earner’s own spending and their retirement contributions all fall away. The figure to use is what the rest of the family actually lives on.

What the simple version leaves out. A precise calculation would account for what the payout earns while it is drawn down, and for inflation pushing costs up over fourteen years. Leaving both out keeps the arithmetic readable; treat the result as a reasonable order of magnitude rather than an exact answer.

The partner without a paycheck, sized

Run the same exercise for the part-time parent. If childcare and household help would cost roughly $20,000 a year for the next ten years, and their part-time income contributes another $15,000 a year the household relies on, their gap is in the region of $350,000, less any coverage they already hold. That number is often a surprise to families who had assumed it was zero.

When to run it again

A new child. A new or refinanced mortgage. A large change in income. A divorce or remarriage. Leaving a job that carried the workplace policy. Otherwise, every three to five years, alongside the beneficiary check that belongs to every November.

Leave a Reply